Best Home Insurance in New York (2023)

Compare personalized Home insurance rates in New York

Home Insurance in New York

When it comes time to renew your homeowners insurance in New York, it is worth taking a closer look to see if you can find cheap homeowners insurance from other providers. Once you know what the New York homeowners requirements are, you can then begin your search to find a cost-effective policy. To help you, we have a comprehensive plan here to guide you to compare all of your options.

Home Insurance Companies in New York

Homeowners insurance agencies in New York have a wide range of options available to you. However, your goal should be to look for the top rated home insurance companies in New York based on their reputation for good service, coverage options, and financial stability. The best home insurance companies in New York can also provide you with discounts and bundles to reduce your costs. You can contact and work with independent home insurance agents in New York for more support or use our process here.


How to Get the Best Rates for Home Insurance in New York

To get started, you need to have a list of companies to work with available in your area. To get it, enter your zip code in the box on this page.


<zipcode>Find The Cheapest Home Insurance In Your Area:</zipcode>


How Much Does Homeowners Insurance Cost in New York?

Where you live matters, which is why getting custom home insurance quotes in New York for your specific home is important. However, to know if you have the cheapest home insurance in New York, you need to have something to compare it by. That is where a few averages can help you. The average in the U.S. for a HO-3 policy is $1,173 annually. The average annual premium in New York is slightly higher at $1,287.


<twitter>The average in the U.S. for a HO-3 policy is $1,173 annually. The average annual premium in New York is slightly higher at $1,287.</twitter>


List of Homeowners Insurance Companies in New York

To help you, we’ve created a list of home insurance companies available in New York for your local area. Just enter your zip code here to receive a copy of this list.

How Homeowners Insurance Is Calculated in New York

Insurance companies must use a wide range of data points to determine risks. In New York, the area is so diverse this can be very important to consider on a local level. However, they do look at state-wide data, too, such as the following.


<qa>1;Crime;Crime in New York, as a whole is very low. Nationally, there are 24 incidents of property crime for every 1,000 residents in a community. In New York, the rate is lower at 15.14. That helps to keep home insurance costs lower than high-risk areas.</qa>

<qa>2;Weather/Climate;Weather is an important factor in every area. New York may be known for its cold and ice, but it also has inland and coastal flooding. Severe storms cause wind and hail damage throughout the year, too. This can increase costs and risk factors for homeowners, pushing home insurance rates higher.</qa>

<qa>3;Home Values;Home values are very particular to the area itself and to the home. Yet, it can help you to know what the average is in the state. As of April of 2019, the median home value in the state of New York is $294,200.</qa>

Home Insurance Requirements in New York

Insurance policies can be a bit overwhelming with their formal details. You should always feel as though you can ask your insurance company any questions you have. Here are some basic insights from questions many people ask.

Is Homeowners Insurance Required in New York?

The law does not require property owners to maintain any specific type of insurance coverage. However, it is common for homeowners associations to have these requirements. Every home with a mortgage will have a clause in their policy for comprehensive coverage to be maintained as a requirement of the contract.

What Does Home Insurance Cover?

Home insurance covers the structure itself and liability risks in New York. This includes protections from theft, storms, vandalism, and much more. Most policies do not include flood insurance outright. You also may need to purchase a rider for anything of a high value you own.

Homeowners Insurance for New Properties in New York

Home insurance in New York needs to be comprehensive for your own protection. New properties have very high dollar values, requiring a high amount of coverage in all cases.

Homeowners Insurance for Old Properties in New York

New York’s older properties may be even more valuable than some new ones. Even if your home value has fallen as your home has aged, it’s well worth having a policy in place to minimize your financial risks.

Renters Insurance in New York

In New York, renting is more common than in other areas, which makes it even more important for you to have a comprehensive renter’s insurance policy. The property owner’s insurance does not protect against loss related to your possessions. This policy can offer that protection.


Renter’s insurance in New York can also be a requirement in some lease agreements. Be sure you know what to expect when signing a contract to lease.


<zipcode>Compare Renters Insurance in New York</zipcode>


Compare Home Insurance in New York by City

As noted, New York is a very diverse area, which means rates differ based on your local significantly. When you compare home insurance quotes in these big cities, you’ll see what is more likely to be what you’ll pay. Remember, the cheapest home insurance in New York for your home has to be specific to your property’s needs.


<qa>1;Home Insurance Quotes in New York City;By far the largest city in the U.S. New York City is home to 8,622,698 people. It’s a modern, upscale, and valuable place to live. The median value of a home here is $681,000 as of April of 2019.</qa>

<qa>2;Home Insurance Quotes in Buffalo, New York;Buffalo is also an important city and one with about 258,612 residents. It’s also a growing area along the western side of the state. The median home value of a home here is $86,000, a significant difference from the eastern area cities.</qa>

<qa>3;Home Insurance Quotes in Rochester, New York;Home insurance in Rochester can be expensive. With 208,046 residents, this area is a critical area for those living closer to the lake. The median value for a home here is $73,800.</qa>

<qa>4;Home Insurance Quotes in Yonkers, New York;Yonkers is a diverse community with much to offer its 202,019 residents. In Yonkers, homeowners can expect the median value of their home to be $507,900.</qa>

<qa>5;Home Insurance Quotes in Syracuse, New York;Known for its colleges, Syracuse is a large community here, too, with 143,396 people calling it home. Home values here are also very low at $87,200.</qa>


Bonus: Most Expensive Homes in New York

If you want the cheapest home insurance in New York, you don’t want to buy a home in some areas. Imagine the cost of these insurance policies.


  1. A townhome with six bedrooms and 20,000 square feet in New York City at 12 E. 69th Street is valued at $88 million.
  2. A condo at 635 W. 42nd Street in New York City with incredible views is valued at $85 million.
  3. Another townhouse, this time at 134 Charles Street, has a value of $80 million.